• Brendan Rodgers  

      Ahead of the Play Off Final tomorrow between Reading and Cardiff it is interesting to see the passion surrounding Brendan Rodgers.

      He has only been a manager for two and a half years but has certainly created some waves in that time

      His first managerial appointment was at Watford where he walked into a maelstrom following the sacking of Aidy Boothroyd and the temporary appointment of Malky Mackay. From the beginning there fans had mixed views as many felt their hero who took them to the Promised land of the Premiership had been unfairly sacked and others like dthe early promise of Mackay. The early weeks of his reign were clouded in mystery too as he failed to sign his contract to begin with and gave a few rather lame excuses – only then to sign. He later claimed that he was not given proper information on Watford’s disastrous finances and there were fears he would walk out.

      From almost freefall towards tLeague One Rodgers stabilised the club and ended the Route One direct football famous at Watford not only from the Graham Taylor era but also under Aidy Boothroyd where many uncomplimentary fans labelled it “hoofball” His record in that season was a quite respectable won 13 drew 7 and lost 12 which moved Watford away from the trapdoor and towards mid table safety. His use of a number of loanees also received mixed feelings – especially as he made numerous references to his time working with Mourinho at Chelsea – dropping it into conversation far too often

      Watford fans were happy by the end of that season and looking forward ot better things to come when Rodgers made a mistake which will forever haunt him around Vicarage Road. Reading were eyeing him up as their Manager to be and there was a lot of speculation that Rodgers would jump ship to return to the club of his youth and early managerial experience. He appeared to squash those rumours with a remark that he was “angry that people were questioning his integrity by suggesting he would break his contract” Only two days later he did just that and has never been forgiven by the Watford faithful

      Well there is a phrase about jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire. This could have been coined ith Rodgers in mind. If he thought he was leaving behind a mess (financially at any rate) for a safe haven his dreams were soon to be shattered.. He followed the almost legendary Steve Coppell in the Reading hot seat and that was always going to be a hard act to follow. He was appointed on 5th June but never got to grips with the task of preparing reading for a new assault on the Premiership. His style was criticised – as it had been at Watford as too much aimless passing – sideways and backwards as well as his now almost famous frequent references to himself and Mourinho. It was result though that told and on 16th December – just a little over 5 months into the job Rodgers was fired – his record a dismal 6 wins 6 draws and 11 defeats.

      He spent the rest of the season out of management but in July was given a new chance when Swansea City appointed him as their replacement for Paolo Sousa who had controversially decamped to Leicester City

      At Swansea he inherited a good squad and made those few tweaks that can make all the difference. His passing game – still controversial in some quarters was nevertheless recognised as statistically his team created more passes than any other including the likes of Arsenal, renowned for their passing game.

      Success gradually grew and with a good end to the season Swansea climbed above their Welsh Arch rivals Cardiff City to 3rd in the table and into the Play Offs for the “biggest prize match in Engklish football” the final at Wembley where success could mena the best part of a £100m extra income for the club. His record at Swansea of 29 wins, 9 draws and 16 defeats – a win percentage of 54% - is impressive.

      Ironically his new team now faces his old one – the Reading who sacked him after such a short time. Who will come out on top now?

      Interestingly Reading and Swansea fans generally have quite positive things to say about him – it is only at Watford where one word “integrity” tarnishes his image and still causes such dislike.

      Tomorrow will decide whether his ambition and skill as a manager can take Swansea to their dream.

       

       

      Comments 8 Comments
      1. goldenboy1993's Avatar
        goldenboy1993 -
        as a watford fan I could never forgive Brenden and I have spoken to reading fans who dont like him either. Come on Reading though!!!!
      1. Hornette_TID's Avatar
        Hornette_TID -
        Good article Leonardo ...like goldenboy, i can't forgive him for that one word that promised so much and meant nothing to him. Of the two teams, i don't want either to win, but if i had to make a choice, it'd be Reading.
      1. Leonardo's Avatar
        Leonardo -
        In looking to write this I visited the old 606 Reading Board and got their comments on BR - most of them still like him and recognise he was not given long enough - but given that McDermott has been so good for them they are happy - it seems it is only really some Watford fans who hate him
      1. Stumpy's Avatar
        Stumpy -
        Couldn't care less what others think of him, he's a Jack now. Watch him on Match of the Day
      1. daipembs's Avatar
        daipembs -
        Brendan has fitted like a glove at Swansea where he inherited a good team that already played a patient Spanish type passing game under previous manager Roberto Martinez. This game plan changed slightly under Soussa who was a defender in his playing days and added a sttely defensive edge to our game. Brendan has embrassed both the above style and has added fire power in the shape of Sinclair, and laterly Borini as the result of his previous Chelsea days. His affable manner with players, fans and his diplomatic way of dealing with the media, where he never slags off opposition or officials has made him a firm favourite with Swansea fans and the next stage of his job is to add to his squad in the usual frugal way that chairman Huw Jenkins insists on, whilst trying to maintain the Swansea passing style which we are becoming renowned for. This will be the acid test for him in the testing times ahead in the Premier League. Time will tell, but us Jacks can't wait for next season now.
      1. Chris 13's Avatar
        Chris 13 -
        I saw Swansea pass us off the park last year and although we nearly got a draw out of it in the end I think it's fair to say they were one of the best teams to visit the Vic last season.

        Obviously we are still harbouring resentment against Rogers because of his promises but that it now subsiding as Malky has shown an ability to play an attractive way with almost no money at all. Let's be honest, one of the reasons we were so upset at the time Rogers left was because we could see what he could do for us had he stayed. He renaiged on his promises to us - but at the time he joined was Simpson honest to him?

        Anyway, it's water well under the bridge now & good luck to The Swans for next year - just promise to come above QPR please?
      1. Leonardo's Avatar
        Leonardo -
        Good post Chris - it is good to see some Hornets getting over the word "integrity" which seems to defeat many.

        It will be interesting to see how Swansea fare in a division where there is a majority of good passing teams - and with more expensive players. This will test to see just how good he is - personally I think he is a very good manager in the making - let's face it he has only 2 and a half years experience - but the Premiership is a tough call for any club not backed by millions

        Good luck and congratulations to the Swansea Jacks
      1. sa1nts's Avatar
        sa1nts -
        Could have gone either way at Wembley (I was there), but stupid defending by Readings 'experienced' defenders gave it to The Swans on a plate really.