The second penalty was a soft one

[Antonio-Valencia]

But we should of had a penalty or two in the first half anyway, so its fair

[shwan]

tbh both were .. but seen them given
but we should had 2 penalties at first half, 2-0 up and they down to 10 men.. but muppet WEBB screwed the game for us .. that could had be an easy win today .. and he kept them in the game

[United-Road]

Amen to that

[shwan]

But we should of had a penalty or two in the first half anyway, so its fair

2-0 up and they reduced to 10 men !! NO.. nothing fair about that.. we have been robbed

[Miggins]

2 penalties? I didn't see any, I saw Welbeck get fouled outside the box, stagger to the inside and drop like a stone, and saw Man utd players throwing themselves to the floor without abandon, as usual, but actual penalties? no, there were none.

[Swarbs]

2 penalties? I didn't see any, I saw Welbeck get fouled outside the box, stagger to the inside and drop like a stone, and saw Man utd players throwing themselves to the floor without abandon, as usual, but actual penalties? no, there were none.

So you're saying Gary Cahill should've been sent off before Chelsea had scored? Brave call....

[UNITED SINCE 63]

Webb gave us two penalties out of four possibles, apart from that he could quite easily have sent two Chelski players off and I thought he gave them every 50/50 decision. We were in control of the game all afternoon and but for two lucky deflected own goals should have won easily. Chelski are a spent force and they need "The special one " back if they are going to challenge for trophies next year !!!!

[Drogs]

2 penalties? I didn't see any, I saw Welbeck get fouled outside the box, stagger to the inside and drop like a stone, and saw Man utd players throwing themselves to the floor without abandon, as usual, but actual penalties? no, there were none.

Spot on

[Drogs]

2 penalties? I didn't see any, I saw Welbeck get fouled outside the box, stagger to the inside and drop like a stone, and saw Man utd players throwing themselves to the floor without abandon, as usual, but actual penalties? no, there were none.

So you're saying Gary Cahill should've been sent off before Chelsea had scored? Brave call....

Swarbs, darling, Welbeck tripped over Cahills straggling leg! Cahill moved the ball just enough and welbeck droped about 2 seconds after.

I think it was a reasonable result but i'm pissed off in how we gave it away.

[Christiansmith]

If we were going to have a draw then this one was good. It felt almost like a victory because we were staring at a 3-0 defeat. I will admit to feeling very worried that it could have been 4-5 nil if we wnet all out for a goal. I thought here we go again: the City match again, with us chasing a goal and leaving ourselves open at the back.

[littleDinosaurLuke]

A foul in the penalty box is a penalty.

No need for a two footed tackle or use of machete, machine gun etc.

Why do people think that certain fouls in the penalty box are acceptable?

[Daveunited]

tbh both were .. but seen them given
but we should had 2 penalties at first half, 2-0 up and they down to 10 men.. but muppet WEBB screwed the game for us .. that could had be an easy win today .. and he kept them in the game

if we were given the 1st penalty the game would have changed,but as they all say "its all ifs and buts"

[Drogs]

A foul in the penalty box is a penalty.

No need for a two footed tackle or use of machete, machine gun etc.

Why do people think that certain fouls in the penalty box are acceptable?

How about ones that are clear cut 100% and not pathetic little trip ups.

[stopthepress]

I think Webb was just guessing. Giving penalties on the basis that he hadn't given the earlier ones.

[Manobear]

First one was penalty IMO, second one wasn't, but it wasn't nearly as bad as Johnson's flop against Fulham. Welbeck didn't have to throw his leg sideways to make contact.!

[Constcrepe]

First one was penalty IMO, second one wasn't, but it wasn't nearly as bad as Johnson's flop against Fulham. Welbeck didn't have to throw his leg sideways to make contact.!

Young foul was by the law a foul however Ashley's fall to the ground didn't help him. The Cahill one was a clearly a foul but the initial foul was outside the box but a red card. The Evra foul - penalty no question. The foul on Danny similar yes you are right to the Johnson one against Fulham but not as bad a leg throw! Didn't hear the ABU's crying about that one. TBH I'd be gutted if that penalty decision had went against us but pleased it was in our favour.

[Drogs]

Ffs, Young - not a foul, Welbeck - tripped up and threw himself over, Evra - stonewall pen, Welbeck 2 - almost the same as his first horrible acting.

Not to mention all the soft **** Webb gave all over the park.

Once again, we were mugged off by a ref against United. You couldn't score fair goals from open play bar your 3rd so you had to rely on a referee's decision AGAIN.

[Swarbs]

Swarbs, darling, Welbeck tripped over Cahills straggling leg! Cahill moved the ball just enough and welbeck droped about 2 seconds after.

I think it was a reasonable result but i'm pissed off in how we gave it away.

Didn't actually see it as I was driving at the time. The 5Live summariser seemed pretty convinced it was a foul, as did the Beeb, Guardian and Telegraph live text summaries. And also Miggins.

If there's a link to a decent quality vid anywhere I'll take a look and let you know what I think

[Manciniiiiiii]

Didn't actually see it as I was driving at the time. The 5Live summariser seemed pretty convinced it was a foul, as did the Beeb, Guardian and Telegraph live text summaries. And also Miggins.

If there's a link to a decent quality vid anywhere I'll take a look and let you know what I think

Left early again did you Swarbs?

[Swarbs]

Left early again did you Swarbs?

Was driving my daughter home from a birthday party. You know, a daughter is one of those things you get when you are able to convince a woman to sleep with you. Don't worry, you'll get there one day

P.S. Your IP address now says you are in Southampton. What's the matter, Saints not won enough for you to support them?