poll..best keeper on the books

who is the best keeper we have

 

the best we have on our books
not the one you want to stay cause his wages are lower

or you could just vote for the other one

 

Green because he gives a @@@@
In second place the other one (Murphy) because he gives a @@@@


There is no-one else to consider

 

For me a question that is unanswerable.
Quality wise has to be Cesar......But I couldn't vote for that mercenary b****** if my life depended on it.

 

Obviously, Rob Green. He will be our #1 for the next 3 or 4 seasons.

 

Our best keeper is cesar

 

You reckon?

I believe that Green's contract expires at the end of this season, while Cesar will still have two years on his. So if we can't shift Cesar .....

 

The people who say 'Green is better than Cesar' are the same people still crying for Mackie and Adel back in the team. Cesar is far better, his record proves it. He isn't even playing yet can still walk in to Brazils national squad, Green isn't even considered for England and we're ****.

Unfortunately Cesar is teaching the board why you negotiate a contract rather than letting an agent dictate the terms, some hate Cesar for staying, but which one of you would really let yourself be forced away from earning that much money if you didn't have to?

I like Green, seems a nice bloke and I'm more than happy with the way he's played this season. I just think if we really wanted rid of Cesar, what better way than putting him in the team so people can actually see him play? If Green's contract is going to expire at the end of this season and we can't get rid of Cesar, would we renew Green's contract? That will be a tough decision to make.

 

The OP question was 'Who is the best keeper?'

As the Brazilian national stopper and winner of golden gloves http://www.qpr.co.uk/news/article/140114-cesar-picks-up-golden-glove-award-1292062.aspx
he is way above Rob Green.

People need to separate his undoubted abilities from the ridiculous contract Swiss Tony and Phil 'Teflon' Beard agreed with him

 

Based on the question it probably is Cesar.....

 

Cesar is the better keeper. He's not as good as he was a few years' back, but he is the best keeper on our books.

The other issues we all know about, but the question was who is the best keeper.

 

Cesar could be ultimately better keeper overall, but as playing in hoops theres not much difference. They both were awful against Swansea last season for excample.....

 

Cesar may have given a ****e if he'd been playing.

The fact that Murphy's been on the bench proves he's been frozen out and so, while Green may have done everything we could reasonably expect, we'll never know if Cesar would have earnt is a few more points or cost us some.

Ignoring his wages, contracts and transfer status, he is a wonderful talent and would be playing if it was me calling it.

 

What beth said

 

Wot Staines said

 

I hope people are aware that this award was for the Confederations cup last summer? Manuel Neuer won the Golden Gloves for best goalkeeper in the world.

 

Going on this seasons performances then my choice is Green

 

Best keeper?
Cesar without a doubt, you cannot compare Brasils #1 against a guy who cant get in the england squad ahead of some really poor goalies.

Best keeper to play?
Green.

 

Hmm couldn't answer Cesar not because I think Green is the better keeper but because towards the end he wouldn't put his body on the line which I believe is a vital part of being a keeper, therefore Green is the better keeper for us.

 

I voted Green but I don't want Mackie back and I hope I never see Taarabt in a Rangers shirt again. I used to really like Mackie but Nines' builder's story turned me right of the greedy get. Redknapp was right to let the wantaway cu*t go.

Regarding Cesar being better citing his record, to be honest when it comes to Rangers players, I'm never interested in their record at other Clubs or indeed their potential to be a star at a future club. All that is irrelevant to me. I only go on what I see the player do in the hoops (or whatever colour in the GK's case) and in Cesar's case he's been average. The reason I say this is because all his howlers in the crucial run in last season cancelled out his top drawer performances earlier in the season. If a Keeper doesn't make any outstanding saves but equally doesn't drop any clangers then he's simply average. If a Keeper makes great saves but drops regular clangers then he's bog-standard an' all. It ultimately works out the same as far as I'm concerned.

Green played some great games last year but some awful ones too but crucially this season he's not put a foot wrong and the defence seem comfortable with him at their back. For that reason I think Green edges it.