One on the left for me ( preferably with a different logo ), one on the right doesn't look like a Toon top to me.
Left **** Right good collar looks miles better but needs more black and a reasonable sponsor logo to look anything other than a supermarket sweep outfit
The one on the right is a photoshop. The person who created it took Borrussia D's kit style and ammended it to newcastle's colours, sponsers and Badge. The other kit doing the rounds is this one! please log in to view this image
There are new images of the shirts that appear to be more real as opposed to cgu please log in to view this image