Carroll bid rejected

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,11678_6708608,00.html

What do you lot think?

Personally I would love it if we signed him. He offers us what Crouch does but he's just better at it in every way, i.e. he can kick a ball better than a 8 year old girl. £23 million in my opinion is abit too much but as its the January transfer window, and he's English and because Villa ****ed everything up by paying a potential £24 million for Bent, it's likely that it'll be more.

What is everyone elses thoughts, forget the fee and focus on the player, will he make us better?

COYS

 

He looks the part LDS but Pardew is determined to keep him and might well walk if NUFC sold him. It would be a big surprise if we signed him.

 

I mentioned on an article on 606 about a month ago saying i would love him to sign for us because working with Ferdinand and Allen would do wonders for his game let alone playing in a team with VDV, Bale, Lennon and Modric creating chances for him to feed off. I agree we more than likely won't sign him but I see it mainly coming from him not wanting to leave just yet, unless they accept a bid I can't see him pushing Newcastle to let him leave like Torres is doing now

 

They are testing Newcastle to see if Carroll puts in a transfer like Torres, that won't happen.

 

look,ask yourselves this,who are the most likely to be in the champions leaguefor the next few years?which team are more likely to win cups n titles?arsenal?chelsea?man c?man u?spurs?if carol wanted to leave he would of put a request in when chelsea made an enquiry(chelsea by the way have behaved with more dignity than you lot)so i dont know wether you lot have been to thetitus bramble school of no, or wot,but carol would have a choice of clubs to go to, who do you think he would pick

 

Carroll wouldn't get in the starting XI of those 4 clubs, and of course Arsenal and City aren't exactly laden with trophies

 

As a player, he has a lot of atributes that we need in our team now. As a person he's a bit of plank and I think that might get worse if he comes to London on a big salary with a big ego.

 

Chelsea have behaved with more dignity?! WTF! All we have done is bid for a player which was made public by NEWCASTLE! Get a grip you ****ing imbecile!

 

About time you Spuds brought through you own talent from your youth policy or dont you have one

 

We prefer to give to Northern charity cases, It makes us feel like we're giving something back!!

This months chosen charity is "take a thick Geordie out of the northern slums"

 

I think Crouchie is a much better all round player than My Little Pony

 

Carroll doesnt want to leave, non starter

 

i think you will find the standard of living is better up here

 

Oh Carol!

 

Indeed I hear the council houses up there are top notch.

 

they are they dont have twenty albanians in them

 

You're right he'll stay at his boyhood club forever.

 

Annoyed we didn't get him to be honest but as he cost £35 million i'll get over it easily, he's good but not worth that

 

Agreed, he's the sort of player we need but not for £35m.