Regular Season Ratings

As it says, rate each player out of ten based on performances...

Gavin Bazunu
Kyle Walker-Peters
Taylor Harwood-Bellis
Jan Bednarek
Ryan Manning
Flynn Downes
Will Smallbone
Stuart Armstrong
Adam Armstrong
Che Adams
Ryan Fraser
Jack Stephens
James Bree
Joe Aribo
Shea Charles
David Brooks
Kamaldeen Sulemana
Samuel Edozie
Sekou Mara
Joe Rothwell
Carlos Alcaraz
Alex McCarthy
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw
Tyler Dibling
Jayden Meghoma
Joe Lumley

Russell Martin

 

Gavin Bazunu - 5
Kyle Walker-Peters - 8
Taylor Harwood-Bellis - 8
Jan Bednarek - 8
Ryan Manning - 4
Flynn Downes - 9
Will Smallbone - 6.5
Stuart Armstrong - 7
Adam Armstrong - 7.5
Che Adams - 7
Ryan Fraser - 7
Jack Stephens - 6.5
James Bree - 5.5
Joe Aribo - 7
Shea Charles - 6.5
David Brooks - 6
Kamaldeen Sulemana - 4
Samuel Edozie - 6.5
Sekou Mara - 6
Joe Rothwell - 4.5
Carlos Alcaraz - 6
Alex McCarthy - 6
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw - 6
Tyler Dibling - 6
Jayden Meghoma - 6
Joe Lumley - 6

Russell Martin - 6

 

Gavin Bazunu 6
Kyle Walker-Peters 8
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 8
Jan Bednarek 8
Ryan Manning 7
Flynn Downes 9
Will Smallbone 8
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 9
Che Adams 7
Ryan Fraser 7
Jack Stephens 7
James Bree 7
Joe Aribo 8
Shea Charles 6
David Brooks 6
Kamaldeen Sulemana 6
Samuel Edozie 7
Sekou Mara 5
Joe Rothwell 7
Carlos Alcaraz 6
Alex McCarthy 7
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 6
Tyler Dibling 6
Jayden Meghoma 6
Joe Lumley 6

Russell Martin - 8 (controversial, but overall we have been smiling more often than not this year)

 

Gavin Bazunu 6
Kyle Walker-Peters 7.5
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 7.5
Jan Bednarek 7.5
Ryan Manning 5.5
Flynn Downes 9
Will Smallbone 7.5
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 9
Che Adams 7.5
Ryan Fraser 7
Jack Stephens 7
James Bree 6.5
Joe Aribo 7
Shea Charles 6
David Brooks 6.5
Kamaldeen Sulemana 5
Samuel Edozie 6.5
Sekou Mara 4
Joe Rothwell 5.5
Carlos Alcaraz 6
Alex McCarthy 6
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 5.5
Tyler Dibling 6
Jayden Meghoma 6
Joe Lumley 6

Russell Martin 8

 

Gavin Bazunu 7
Kyle Walker-Peters 9
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 8.5
Jan Bednarek 8
Ryan Manning 6.5
Flynn Downes 8.5
Will Smallbone 8
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 8.5
Che Adams 7.5
Ryan Fraser 7.5
Jack Stephens 7
James Bree 7
Joe Aribo 8
Shea Charles 7
David Brooks 7.5
Kamaldeen Sulemana 6
Samuel Edozie 7
Sekou Mara 6.5
Joe Rothwell 6
Carlos Alcaraz 6
Alex McCarthy 7
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 7
Tyler Dibling 6.5
Jayden Meghoma 6.5
Joe Lumley 6

Russell Martin 8

 

Gavin Bazunu 6
Kyle Walker-Peters 8
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 7
Jan Bednarek 7.5
Ryan Manning 6
Flynn Downes 8.5
Will Smallbone 6
Stuart Armstrong 7.5
Adam Armstrong 8
Che Adams 7
Ryan Fraser 6.5
Jack Stephens 6.5
James Bree 5
Joe Aribo 7.5
Shea Charles 6.5
David Brooks 6.5
Kamaldeen Sulemana 5.5
Samuel Edozie 6
Sekou Mara 5
Joe Rothwell 6
Carlos Alcaraz 5.5
Alex McCarthy 6.5
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 6
Tyler Dibling 6
Jayden Meghoma 6
Joe Lumley 6

Russell Martin 5

 

I feel a bit for Sekou being scored lower by people than Kamaldeen. At least he actually contributed *something* this season.

 

Gavin Bazunu 5
Kyle Walker-Peters 9
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 8
Jan Bednarek 9
Ryan Manning 5.5
Flynn Downes 8
Will Smallbone 7
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 9
Che Adams 8
Ryan Fraser 8
Jack Stephens 7
James Bree 6
Joe Aribo 7
Shea Charles 6
David Brooks 6
Kamaldeen Sulemana 5
Samuel Edozie 6
Sekou Mara 4
Joe Rothwell 5
Carlos Alcaraz na
Alex McCarthy 6
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw na
Tyler Dibling na
Jayden Meghoma na
Joe Lumley na

Russell Martin 7

 

Gavin Bazunu 6
Kyle Walker-Peters 8
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 8
Jan Bednarek 8
Ryan Manning 6
Flynn Downes 9
Will Smallbone 7
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 8
Che Adams 7
Ryan Fraser 7
Jack Stephens 7
James Bree 7
Joe Aribo 7
Shea Charles 6
David Brooks 6
Kamaldeen Sulemana 5
Samuel Edozie 6
Sekou Mara 4
Joe Rothwell 5
Carlos Alcaraz 7
Alex McCarthy 6
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 7
Tyler Dibling 7
Jayden Meghoma 8
Joe Lumley 7

Russell Martin 7

 

Gavin Bazunu 6
Kyle Walker-Peters 8
Taylor Harwood-Bellis 8
Jan Bednarek 7
Ryan Manning 5
Flynn Downes 9
Will Smallbone 7
Stuart Armstrong 8
Adam Armstrong 9
Che Adams 7
Ryan Fraser 6
Jack Stephens 6
James Bree 5
Joe Aribo 7
Shea Charles 6
David Brooks 7
Kamaldeen Sulemana 5
Samuel Edozie 5
Sekou Mara 6
Joe Rothwell 6
Carlos Alcaraz 6
Alex McCarthy 6
Samuel Amo-Ameyaw 6
Tyler Dibling 6
Jayden Meghoma 6
Joe Lumley 5

Russell Martin 4

 

Martin gets a 4 from me because from what I've seen, it's been the quality of the squad that has got us to 4th. He can't turn a game round when it's going wrong. It's been a mainly fun season because we've been racking up goals against far inferior opponents rather than his tactics.

 

Nah, we've never come from behind to get a point or 3 this season, none at all ... everyone was praising him earlier in the season based on his in-game tactical changes winning us points. You're being very harsh there I feel.

Oh how fickle fans are ...

 

I'm not necessarily talking about games where we've gone behind. It's the games where the other manager has made changes and Martin does **** all about it. So we go from dominating one half to either hanging on or blowing a lead.

 

However, even this late in the season, If we have one sub to make and the choice is Kamaldean or Sekou, I want the former.

 

I have shown it before but to repeat we are miles behind the other teams in the top 6 at positive game management. Way behind in both keeping leads and turning deficits into wins.

 

Yep, which is why I've graded Martin so poorly.

 

I think that the Saints manager with the highest win ratio since the 19th century and that oversaw the longest winning streak in over a 100 years warrants more than a 4 personally, it's a little bit insulting imo.

 

I gave him a 5

 

Yeah that's more like it...

 

I'd rather keep the sub spare and leave them both on the bench